Critic's Scorecard

Submitted by Wesley R. Elsberry on Wed, 2006-08-30 00:42. Critic's Scorecard

This is the starting point for a collaborative project. The idea here is to gather together the scattered information concerning criticism of antievolutionary ideas and rhetoric and make it available in a readily-accessible form. This is to be, essentially, a compilation of a history of ideas.

Format of entries

It will be useful to standardize on an entry format so that readers don't have to try to interpret several different ways of presenting information.

DRAFT

Needed information per entry:

Topic of criticism (include keywords so search will return the entry)

» read more | 9299 reads

RSS Syndication

AE Site RSS Feed

PvM's Blog RSS

AE Public BB RSS Feed

Antievolutionists Say the Darndest Things

Antievolutionists often express outrage over alleged incivility from those who oppose their efforts to evade the establishment clause of the First Amendment. But they have no difficulty in dishing out the abuse themselves. Here is a sample from the Invidious Comparisons thread that documents egregious behavior on the part of the religious antievolution advocates.

IDC advocate Mark Hartwig:

The intimidation tactics, however, signal something important about Darwinists. That "something" was explained in an insightful little piece by one A.J. Obrdlik. Published in 1942, it was a study of "gallows humor" in Czechoslovakia during the Nazi occupation. In that article, Obrdlik made a very keen observation:

Gallows humor is a reliable index of the morale of the oppressed whereas the reaction to it on the part of the oppressors tells a long story about the actual strength of the dictators: If they can afford to ignore it, they are strong; if they react wildly with anger, striking their victims with severe reprisals and punishment, they are not sure of themselves, no matter how much they display their might on the surface.

With the growing success of the Wedge, I'm sure we're going to see a lot more of this stuff. But Darwinist tactics will become a lot less intimidating as people realize that they signify not strength but panic.

Link

Pro-Science Sites

The TalkOrigins Archive: Mainstream science answers to antievolution arguments.
TalkDesign.org: Mainstream science answers to "intelligent design" arguments.
National Center for Science Education: Non-profit organization to defend the teaching of evolution in public schools.
Understanding Evolution: UCMP/NCSE site for science education in evolution.
Alabama Citizens for Science
Colorado Citizens for Science
Florida Citizens for Science
Georgia Citizens for Science Education
Kansas Citizens for Science
Michigan Citizens for Science
Nebraska
New Mexico
New Mexico - CESE
New Mexico - NMSR
Ohio Citizens for Science
Texas Citizens for Science
Washington - BECSE
Wisconsin Citizens for Science

Who's online

Navigation

User login

Static Site Links

Featured Book

Donate

Random Articles

Store

Advertisements

Critic's Scorecard

Critic's Scorecard

Format of entries

RSS Syndication

Antievolutionists Say the Darndest Things

Pro-Science Sites

Donate \| NCSE \| PT \| TD \| TOA \| Public BB Archive \| PvM's Blog